I have to admit, I struggle to
leave school at a decent time because I love for my desk to be completely neat.
If I do leave at a decent time, I do my work at home. Uhhh! Routman says to
leave it at school, but I’m not sure that will happen. I do; however, have days
that I do nothing so that I can get some rest. I am guilty of going home early,
at like 4 or 4:30, and playing with Easton, my son, having dinner and talking.
Then I stay up late working. This year has been the worse because of all that I
have going on. Like Routman states on page 202, I like to plan with the idea of
my students. I cannot plan for a whole month or unit until I understand what my
students know, their interests, purposes and goals. Routman’s chart on page 203
reflects the questions for Safe-T, which I am finishing up this year. Yay! The
questions make everyone reflect on what the students need to know, all the way
to what needs to change. Modifications are necessary for all class plans
because every student learns differently, based on the topic or subject.
Routman discusses having “authentic reading and writing in which students have
some challenge, choice, control, and opportunity to collaboratively motivate
students most” (204). This is the reason why I have believe in Balanced
Literacy and Reading and Writing workshop!!! I want my students to create
reading and writing on the spot!!! To think and analyze like little Einstein
children. Most of all, I want them to be responsible for their own learning! Routman
discusses authentic learning a lot in their chapter, she wants teachers to do
this. So I can now pop out an assessment quickly to ensure that my students have
an authentic assessment. I can create questions that make them think, but I
want them to do the same. I feel that Routman would agree. The section in which
Routman wants us to keep work simple is relevant because with only so much
time, the students need to have experiences, but complete them. I feel that
last year, when I used the textbook and the textbook assessments, the tests
were way too long and made the students and I have to figure out what it was
asking exactly. It did not build on their understanding or make any moments
count as Routman wants on page 205.
Although I feel that my relationships with my students in the past are
still reflected, I do feel that I have connected with my students on their
reading and writing more this year. I do understand where Routman is coming
from when she talks about assessing, then teaching, then assessing. I feel that
the only way that I can truly believe in Reading and Writing workshop is to do
this. She talks about doing Running records. These are done through conferencing
each day with my students. Conferencing has allowed for me to work one on one
with each of my students. While conferencing, Routman believes that we should
tell students their strengths and weaknesses (205). I do feel that I struggle
with allowing students to know their weakness because I do not want to upset
them or make them feel negative about their reading. I try and find everything
positive about their reading, but do understand that they need to understand
both to become stronger readers and writers.
I love everything on page 206 of
Routman’s tips because I find that I also call on students that do not volunteer
to give ideas and I have my distracted students in the front closest to my
desk. However, I am constantly moving so I have to make the students feel that
the desk is close to me. I also agree with “Keep a lively pace” because some of
my students get distracted if there is too much time spent on one topic (206). On
another hand, I like to keep my students hanging so that they want to read
more, or explore the activity more. I do want more time with my struggling
students (207) because I feel that they have so much that they could offer the
class if only they could get past their struggles! Also I would love to try the
“mystery words” (208) with vocabulary words or with spelling words. It would be
a fun way to get them to play with their words.
I feel that this year, I have used
the resources in the room for students. Last year, my library was there with
little interaction. This year, my students use it almost every day, which makes
me excited. I also feel validated in not using my crayons as much for coloring.
I find with our new curriculum, we don’t have enough time to color. I also find
that my students will draw better if I tell them that they can only use their
pencils (210).
Routman really wants us to
communicate with other teachers. I agree, building relationships will help you
teach more purposely. Even though I am not in control of the list on page 216,
I do agree with hiring roving subs, having a late start once a week, which I have
done for Bullying meetings, loved adding paid days to school calendar and
adding more time to the school day. With only so much time, I would like for
the school days to be longer, but with less days. I feel that when I am
teaching, I do not want to continue the same idea the next day, I want to
finish my work for that day. Extending the day would help this to happen. I
also agree with Routman on page 217 because I feel that professional
development and reading does keep me learning and growing as a learner and in
turn, as a teacher. I expect my students to grow, and they expect me to as
well. I want to try new things and introduce new, interesting learning/teaching
techniques (217-218) to keep my students and I engaged!
You are so right, Angie. We can't just plan out a whole unit--or even rely upon a unit we taught in a previous year--because we need to meet the needs of our students, this year, today. Paying close attention to our students' strengths and needs through formative assessments should inform our teaching. Maybe we should call them informative assessments. :-) I know you celebrate your students' strengths, and pointing out areas of weakness can be uncomfortable if we think mistakes are bad. But if you frame those mistakes and miscues as opportunities to grow, it is more hopeful and encouraging.
ReplyDeleteHi Angie,
ReplyDeleteI love that you have discovered the inherent problem in planning out our entire curriculum with day by day lessons without knowing our students. Routman's chapter matches my heart in explaining that who we teach is just as important (I would argue more) than what we teach. This isn't to say we don't need to know our content and know our standards and have a plan for reaching these - but creating a guide is different then creating a scripted plan.