As I read this section of the book I thought about what I am
currently doing to teach my students how to read. After I read this article I was scrolling
through Facebook and I saw a quote, “children are made readers on the laps of
their parents” E. Buchwald. That quote
made my wheels start turning! I wondered
how many of my students had a parent that read to them at home. The next day I came in and about a third of
my class said their parents read with them before they go to bed at night. I then went on to ask how many of them had
ever been to the public library. Most of
them had a puzzled look on their face but four or five said they go to the
library. I thought that maybe they did
not understand what I was asking so I showed them pictures of the Spartanburg
library branches, still them same result. I then reflected on all of the
statistics that I read in Section 2 of this book and I thought especially about
page 21 that talked about how much kids need to read in order to become
successful readers. It discussed
language-minority first graders and what they need to become independent
readers. Can I do all of this on my own?
I know that most of my students depend on our school for their reading
materials. Do my students read at home? Can
I encourage them to go to the public library? If only the parents would take
them to the library? Do they know that it’s
free? Is transportation a problem? Can the book mobile come and give them
access to more books? My classroom
library does not have enough books to help my students reach their
potential. I wish it did but I do not
have the money to buy that many books.
If I used the genre wheel (figure 2-2) on page 20 my students would have
a very sad looking wheel.
The main point in this section is that teachers play such an
important role in students reading; we must choose help them choose books and
we must confer with them while they are reading. I felt good about this (compared to thinking
about my classroom library) because we are doing the Daily 5 and the students
read so much! I get to listen to them and help them read. I talk to them multiple times a week and keep
notes about their progress. My students
get to choose what they want to read and I think that is going to play a big
role this year. I think reading this
along with the Daily 5 is going to help me become a better teacher and help my
students become better readers.
My biggest concern with all of this is how to grade the
students. Do they all earn a 100 because
they are reading and working hard?
Should the students that read on a lower reading level earn a lower
grade than the students that read on a higher level? I would like to work with other teachers so
that the grading is consistent across the board. I don’t want my students to get to second
grade and have high grades but not be able to read or vice versa. I think the students are going to grow as
readers but I need to find a good way to assess their reading.
There is lots of deep thinking going on here, Jessica!! I love how you go one step beyond the place where some people stop--"My kids don't have families that read to them at home"--and you've already started thinking of ways to increase access to books at home. This is one of my personal interests, too. I also wonder if there are ways families practice literacy at home, even if it's not the way it looks at school. I'm glad that you're feeling comfortable with conferencing, and your questions about grading show me how deeply you are thinking about this topic. I agree that we need to continue this conversation with other teachers to come to an agreement about equitable grading for all students.
ReplyDeleteHi Jessica,
ReplyDeleteYou brought up some great points in your post related to student access to books and how to grade student work in a reading workshop. I am thrilled that this morning Mr. Rollins shared how he has a contact with the Spartanburg Public Library who is working on a book mobile schedule to our school community. I am also excited about the Scholastic books that have come in and the opportunities have to choose books they want to read. Mrs. Wells and I have talked about ways to support you with obtaining grades in reading/writing workshop and this will be provided in an upcoming grade level meeting at Arcadia in Dec. I appreciate you vocalizing what you need because it helps us plan our profess. dev. so that it is meaningful and relevant. Sincerely, Dawn